Excommunication Podcast Podcast By Melissa Vegas and Scott Roeben cover art

Excommunication Podcast

Excommunication Podcast

By: Melissa Vegas and Scott Roeben
Listen for free

Exes talk about movies, TV shows, streaming entertainment, love and romance and situationships, the whole nine.2026 Art
Episodes
  • Ep. 5: Oscar Nom Round-Up
    Mar 12 2026

    Scott and Melissa return for another episode of "Excommunication," where they check the numbers after discovering their last show had a 60/40 speaking split. Determined to rebalance the conversation, they dive into a wide-ranging discussion about movies, pop culture and a bizarre controversy at the BAFTAs.

    The episode begins with a debate about an uncomfortable moment at the BAFTAs involving Tourette's syndrome and a shouted racial slur during a live broadcast. Scott and Melissa unpack the complicated questions around disability, responsibility and whether the awards show mishandled the situation.

    From there the conversation shifts to the movies of the moment. First up is "Train Dreams," which sparks a lively disagreement about what makes a film worth watching. Scott dismisses the slow, plot-light drama as a complete misfire, while Melissa tries to find meaning in its themes about ordinary life, nature and the passage of time.

    They then tackle "One Battle After Another," the latest star-studded film from Paul Thomas Anderson. The two break down the movie's strange tonal shifts, its exaggerated political allegory and whether the characters give audiences anyone to root for. Along the way they discuss Leonardo DiCaprio's frazzled protagonist, Sean Penn's scenery-chewing villain and the challenges of balancing satire, action and comedy in the same film.

    The episode ends with a typical "Excommunication" detour into bald actors, Hollywood vanity, Jason Momoa, and an increasingly absurd conversation about funeral homes, corpse-related rumors and whether any podcast should really end this way.

    It is another unpredictable episode where sharp movie criticism collides with off-the-rails humor, proving once again that "Excommunication" rarely stays on script.

    Show more Show less
    56 mins
  • Ep. 4: Sinners and Weapons
    Mar 12 2026

    In Episode 4 of the "Excommunication Podcast," Scott Roeben and Melissa Vegas dive into a passionate discussion about two Oscar-nominated films, "Weapons" and "Sinners." As always, the conversation begins with some playful housekeeping about podcast habits, interruptions and Scott's alleged inability to remember actors' names, before quickly veering into pop culture, Las Vegas gossip and a debate about Mark Wahlberg's rumored quiet departure from Las Vegas.

    The hosts then break down the horror film "Weapons," which earned a single Oscar nomination. Melissa approaches the movie from the perspective of a horror fan, arguing the film sets up an intriguing mystery but ultimately falls flat due to tonal shifts, implausible plot developments and an over-reliance on familiar tropes. Scott agrees the film fails to deliver on its eerie premise and criticizes its lack of suspense, uneven storytelling and campy execution.

    The discussion then turns to "Sinners," the heavily nominated period vampire film starring Michael B. Jordan. The conversation becomes more philosophical as Scott and Melissa debate the movie's themes, cinematography and cultural context. Melissa praises the film's visual style, production design and performances, while questioning its thin vampire mythology and lack of deeper backstory. Scott takes a more critical view of the screenplay and character choices while acknowledging the film's cultural significance and the importance of supporting diverse voices in filmmaking.

    As with every episode, the discussion includes plenty of detours, jokes and disagreements, including an ongoing argument about how much each host talks during the podcast and what rating system they should use for movies. The result is a lively, unfiltered conversation about film, storytelling and the strange dynamics of reviewing movies with your ex.

    Show more Show less
    1 hr
  • Ep. 3: Pluribus Can't Be Bleat
    Mar 12 2026

    In Episode 3 of the "Excommunication" podcast, Scott Roeben and Melissa Vegas tackle Apple TV+'s buzzy sci-fi series "Pluribus." The conversation begins with some behind-the-scenes "production meeting" feedback about their own podcast habits before shifting into a deep dive on the show, which imagines a mysterious signal that merges the consciousness of nearly every human on Earth into a single hive mind.

    Scott and Melissa explore the premise through the perspective of Carol, one of the few people immune to the phenomenon, and discuss how the series blends familiar apocalyptic tropes with fresh ideas about identity, free will and collective intelligence. They examine the show's central themes, including whether the hive mind represents a benevolent evolution of humanity or something more sinister, and debate the moral questions raised by a world where individuality disappears but violence and conflict vanish with it.

    The episode also touches on the relationship between Carol and her hive-mind guide Zosia, the ethical implications of consent in a shared consciousness, and the broader parallels between the show's premise and the rise of artificial intelligence. Scott and Melissa share their favorite and least favorite episodes, discuss the Las Vegas-set installment that features the Westgate, and speculate about what the remaining immune characters might mean for the story's future.

    As with any "Excommunication" podcast episode, the discussion frequently veers off course into pop culture tangents, language debates and humorous disagreements about everything from zombie storytelling to podcast structure. The result is a free-flowing conversation that reflects the dynamic between two exes who still enjoy arguing about television, ideas and the strange directions a good show can take.

    Show more Show less
    1 hr and 8 mins
No reviews yet