Three Days in the Shenandoah

Stonewall Jackson at Front Royal and Winchester

By: Gary Ecelbarger

Narrated by: Jason Mitchell

The battles of Front Royal and Winchester are the stuff of Civil War legend. Stonewall Jackson swept away an isolated Union division under the command of Nathaniel Banks and made his presence in the northern Shenandoah Valley so frightful a prospect that it triggered an overreaction from President Lincoln, yielding huge benefits for the Confederacy. Gary Ecelbarger has undertaken a comprehensive reassessment of those battles to show their influence on both war strategy and the continuation of the conflict. Three Days in the Shenandoah answers questions that have perplexed historians for generations.

Bypassing long-overused sources that have shrouded the Valley Campaign in myth, Ecelbarger draws instead on newly uncovered primary sources - including soldiers' accounts and officers' reports - to refute much of the anecdotal lore that for too long was regarded as fact. He narrates those suspenseful days of combat from the perspective of battlefield participants and high commanders to weave a compelling story of strategy and tactics. And he offers new conclusions regarding Lincoln's military meddling as commander in chief, grants Jefferson Davis more credit for the campaign than previous accounts have given him, and commends Union soldiers for their fighting.

Written with the flair of a seasoned military historian, Three Days in the Shenandoah reinterprets this important episode. Ecelbarger sets a new standard for envisioning the Shenandoah Campaign that will both fascinate Civil War buffs and engage historians.

©2008 University of Oklahoma Press (P)2016 Redwood Audiobooks

In Depth Military Study

This thorough analysis debunks several common views, and takes the listener into the minds of Jackson and Lincoln. The horror of the many battles in these three days reminds us what is behind the over glorified images of war. I will be listening again.

Needs maps

This analysis of the beginning of Jackson's Valley Campaign provides a great overall analysis. However the very detailed examination of the battles of Front Ryal and Winchester cannot be followed very well unless you have a map in front of you as you listen. Since I listened while driving, I was lost much of the time.

It was pretty good

The details were good However the author seems to really pass judgment 150 later